As Alby Carr, he played four seasons for South Sydney between 1924-1927, including winning the 1926 and 1927 Grand Final's. He also represented New South Wales in 1924 under his alias. He played one last season with South Sydney Rabbitohs in 1930, this time under his correct name of Alby Why. He played one season as Alby Why in 1930 before retiring. He was the brother of Australian Kangaroo, Jack Why.
Alias, and exposure
A newspaper report from 1929 exposed Alby Carr as a 'ring-in' , who was actually Alby Why, the brother of Jack Why. The report was tabled at the NSWRFL on 13 May 1929. Alby Carr's true identity was revealed at the meeting regarding the 'ring-in' allegations. Alby Why tells the story: "I commenced my footballing days at Wellington in 1917. In 1921 he was at Redfern Oval and was asked to play third grade for the Mascot team as 'A.Carr'. Alby Why candidly admitted that he was Alby Carr, in what was known in the turf-world as a 'ring-in'. Then selected as A. Carr, he played one year with Newtown in 1922, then joining the City Houses Competition before being graded with South Sydney Rabbitohs in 1924. During this time and later in England playing with Huddersfield, he retained the name 'Carr', but by 1929 he wished to be recognized by his real name, as his brother Jack Why also played with Souths." 
Albert George Henry Why died on 29 December 1969, aged 70. 
- 14/5/1929 'Why" not Carr. Players name change". Evening News, Sydney. (page 2)
- Alan Whiticker/Glen Hudson: Encyclopedia of Rugby League Players. 1995 (ISBN 1875169571).
- "Alby Why - Coach". Bulldogs. http://www.bulldogs.com.au/main.php?id=14&page=coach. Retrieved 2008-01-02.
- Sydney Morning Herald "Ring-In Football Player - ALBY WHY"S Change of Name". (page 11) article 14-05-1929
- Goulburn Evening Post: (article) "Football Ring-in" "Alby Carr--Alby Why" 14/5/19299
- Evening News, Sydney "Why Not Carr" 14/5/1929
- Sydney Morning Herald: Death Notice- 31/12/1969